Dear Evangelical Black Robe Members,
You captured my attention through Glenn Beck’s Restoring Honor rally, and you’ve attracted a devoted following. In an effort to understand what you’re doing and why, I’ve been looking at your website, and I have a number of questions.
Here is the first sentence on your home page:
The Black Robe Regiment is a resource and networking entity where church leaders and laypeople can network and educate themselves as to our biblical responsibility to stand up for our Lord and Savior and to protect the freedoms and liberties granted to a moral people in the divinely inspired US Constitution [my italics].
The last clause raised many issues for me.
1. Upon what do you base your claim that America was ever “a moral people?” By moral, I assume you mean ethically good. How do you propose to demonstrate that morals in 1776 were good by God’s standards for behavior, equity, and love? Quotations from the founders about the importance of morality will not suffice, since goodness is not in the professing but in the doing.
2. Do you believe that God gave us liberty because we were moral?
I ask because, since you are evangelicals and believe that no form of God’s grace is merited by us, then you must know how suspect that teaching would be.
3. Do you actually believe that the U. S. Constitution is “divinely inspired?” You must be aware that this is Mormon doctrine, and has never been part of the Protestant tradition, founded as it is upon sola scriptura. Why are you, as evangelicals, promoting Mormon mythology?
As a corollary, if you don’t believe the Constitution is divinely inspired, why did you permit the claim in the first sentence of your home page? Who wrote that sentence, and what is his/her theological tradition?
4. Elsewhere, you assert, “The Constitution (Part 1–the Declaration of Independence, and part 2), was and is a covenant between the people of America and their Heavenly Father.”
Let’s leave aside the enormity of asserting that the Declaration is part of the U. S. Constitution. Just answer this: on what possible basis in the Bible do you make the claim that God made a national covenant with Americans?
And again, why are you evangelicals signing on to Mormon myths?
5. In the same paragraph, you also claim,
A people who were honed by thousands of years before Christ walked the Earth by way of the Israelites who had been scattered and dispersed many times in their history. These folks who now inhabited this New Jerusalem (this New Eden that Christopher Columbus saw), were living out what they saw as a life and a country that was fashioned entirely by their Creator.
Are you agreeing with the Mormon tale that native Americans are Israelites?
6. On the same page, you say that “Liberty and Freedom has [sic] been graciously bestowed by our Heavenly Father to each of us. It [sic] has been freely offered, freely sacrificed for by Christ Jesus, and it is the duty of each of us to acknowledge that precious gift and to not give it away lightly.”
Do you believe that Jesus Christ died on the cross to give us political liberty? As evangelicals, surely you must believe that it is liberty from sin and death that Christ purchased. If you want to say that the liberty was also political, you will have to point to some biblical text that not only uses the words liberty and freedom but teaches that these words signify political rights.
7. Why is there no doctrinal statement on your website? How do you propose to advance spiritual revival without stating clearly what the spiritual principles of that revival are, and upon what scriptures those principles are founded?
8. Why is your “networking entity” by invitation only? You say that your site “is an invitation only closed social network for church leaders to freely communicate in a safe environment. We will vet all prospective members to ensure that they are in fact an active church leader.”
It may be that this site does not represent your views of the Gospel or of the Black Robe Regiment. If so, then I invite any evangelical member of the Regiment to disavow the site. State clearly that you do not believe that our Constitution is inspired by God, that it is a covenant with God, or that Americans are a “moral” people descended from the Israelites, but that all Americans are sinners, unable to govern themselves, deserving no favor from God, and who are only freed from their sins by the blood of Christ.
Without straight talk of this kind, I have to conclude that members of the Regiment are fighting to establish a civic deity for Americans — which is to say, an idol.